BSG Ruling of July 23, 2026
A new ruling by the Federal Social Court (Bundessozialgericht, BSG) of July 23, 2026, may have far-reaching consequences for managing majority shareholders: In the court case, two managing shareholders of a GmbH, each holding a 50% stake, were classified as subject to social security contributions. This was due to an arbitration clause in the company’s articles of association that allowed a third party to conduct binding arbitration in the event of disputes between the shareholders.
Default: Managing shareholders with 50% or more of the shares exempt from social security contributions
At first glance, this ruling may come as a surprise. According to established case law, managing majority shareholders in a GmbH are generally exempt from social security contributions. To begin with, managing directors are always subject to the will of the shareholders, as they must comply with resolutions passed by the shareholders’ meeting. However, managing directors holding at least 50% of the shares can block any resolution they do not approve of. Thanks to this veto power, they are consequently considered self-employed and exempt from social security contributions.
Extension to minority shareholders with a statutory veto right
However, shareholders can also grant such a veto right to minority shareholders. If all resolutions require a majority of, for example, 71%, a managing director who holds more than 30% of the shares is also exempt from social security contributions.
Exception for arbitration clauses
In exceptional cases, however, such a veto right does not suffice — namely when, as was the case at the BSG, the shareholders agree to a binding arbitration clause. Then a shareholder cannot ultimately prevent a resolution of the shareholders’ meeting with which he or she disagrees. In the BSG case, a third party was authorized to decide in the event of a dispute, and the 50% shareholders were required to abide by that decision.
Consequences of the court decision
Company contracts under scrutiny
All shareholders who thought they were exempt from social security contributions — whether due to their number of shares or a statutory veto right - should review their articles of association and shareholder agreements as soon as possible to check for an arbitration clause. If they wish to avoid social security obligations going forward, they must amend the articles of association and convert the arbitration clause into a non-binding mediation clause. To do so, however, they need a notarized amendment with a qualified shareholder majority.
Majority Shareholders Are Also at Risk
This social security risk applies not only to shareholders with a blocking minority or equal voting rights, but also to majority shareholders if a veto right has been granted to minority shareholders and the resulting deadlock can be resolved through arbitration. So, taking the BSG’s ruling a step further, in the most extreme case even a shareholder with a 99% stake in the company may become subject to social security contributions.
Conversely, it is possible to flee into social contributions
Conversely, majority shareholders may also choose to become subject to social security contributions. To do so, they need an arbitration clause combined with a blocking minority held by another shareholder or a group of shareholders jointly.
Example of a majority shareholder becoming subject to social security contributions
If, for example, a managing shareholder holds 70% and the other two each hold 15%, the shareholders may stipulate in the articles of association that a qualified majority of 71% is required for all shareholder resolutions. This allows the two minority shareholders to jointly block a resolution proposed by the majority shareholder. Yet, this alone would not result in the majority shareholder being subject to social security contributions. If this veto right is combined with an arbitration clause though just like in the BSG ruling, the arbitrator can theoretically bring about a resolution even against the will of the majority shareholder. This means the latter automatically becomes subject to social security contributions.
Specialized advice from Streiff Law on social security coverage
The social security obligations of managing directors and shareholders concern most founders and companies. And yet, many attorneys and tax advisors lose sight of this topic since it gets lost in the legal Bermuda triangle between corporate law, labor law, and social court proceedings. By contrast, we at Streiff Law are specialized in this topic. Through proactive planning, we can help you achieve your desired outcome with as few concessions as possible. Work with us to clarify and structure your social security obligations early on - ideally as soon as you’re incorporating your GmbH.
Further articles about the obligation to pay social contributions
No managing shareholder needs to pay pension insurance!
How do I determine the social status? And who pays the ensuing social contributions?
Case Studies: social status process, self-employment
Published on 16.11.2026